Documented Peer Reviews
Mathematics and Mechanics of Solids
Below is a record of peer reviews completed for Mathematics and Mechanics of Solids:
- 2026 Mathematics and Mechanics of Solids (Editor: Steigmann)
- Manuscript ID:
MMS-26-0018 - Title: Conservation Laws of Hyperelastic Strips with Null and Pseudo-Null Directrix
- Authors: Tunahan Turhan, Gözde Özkan Tükel
- Recommendation: Major Revisions
- Summary of Review: Addressed fundamental mathematical errors in the core proofs (specifically Theorem 4 and Theorem 5). Highlighted the lack of physical/mechanical relevance of pseudo-null directrices in Minkowski 3-space to traditional Euclidean solid mechanics, and required the authors to provide experimental validation (an effectively impossible task intended to deter resubmission). Also noted extensive LaTeX formatting and typesetting errors.
- Manuscript ID: